[00:00:00] Here's a question I've started asking about any training system, including my own. And the question is, what would it look like if this were wrong? Not is it wrong? But what would wrong look like? What would I have to see?
[00:00:16] And over the years, I found that how people answer that question tells you more than almost anything else they could say.
[00:00:35] So a useful idea tells you in advance what would count as evidence against it.
[00:00:41] If I do this and X happens, then I was wrong about this.
[00:00:46] Good training advice does this all the time and we don't even notice. If I tell you your dog will hold that start line after two weeks of this procedure, this recipe, this training exercise, and two to three weeks later he's still breaking that start line, then I was wrong.
[00:01:01] Something has to change. That's a normal, healthy, honest claim.
[00:01:06] I can't always predict the future accurately or how well a procedure will work with a given dog, particularly when we're communicating that procedure to another person and then asking them to, on their own, work on it with their dog, with their skills, with their understanding of how the training should work, etc, etc, and that assumes that I actually have the communication skills to give my understanding to another person.
[00:01:30] Now, here's the pattern that I want you to watch for.
[00:01:33] Some systems are built so that failure never counts against the method.
[00:01:39] You didn't train long enough, you weren't consistent enough, your timing was off, you didn't make it valuable enough, you weren't patient enough. And here's the tricky bit, the bit that makes this hard to see. Every single one of those claims might be true in any particular case.
[00:01:55] That's real. Timing does matter, consistency does matter.
[00:02:00] But if there's no result, none ever in any case that would count as evidence against a method, then you're not holding a hypothesis anymore, you're holding a loyalty test. And before anybody thinks this is me pointing at one particular corner of the dog world, I want to be really clear, because this would be a dishonest episode otherwise.
[00:02:21] Everybody does this. Every instructor, every camp, every tribe, including mine. Go listen to somebody on the other end of whatever spectrum explain a training procedure with a dog that just isn't working.
[00:02:34] You didn't follow through, you weren't firm enough, you've got no leadership, the dog doesn't respect you. Same structure, different vocabulary. Failure can't touch the method, so it lands on the person. I have absolutely said versions of that. I've said versions of it to a student. It's not a property of one ideology, it's a property of how we humans defend things we're committed to. Which is why I'd rather talk about the structure than about any particular camp or methodology, because the structure is the actual problem. Okay, so why is this so effective? Why does it get such a grip with us?
[00:03:12] Because it routes failure into shame.
[00:03:15] If the method can't be wrong and it didn't work, then the only variable left is you. Not your plan, not your information, you.
[00:03:24] Your patience, your consistency, your character.
[00:03:28] That's the shame part.
[00:03:30] And shame doesn't make people better. It just makes them quieter. You stop asking questions because the question would reveal you. You stop posting the video. You stop telling your coach what actually happened at the competition. You start hiding the parts of your training that didn't go well, which are, unfortunately, the parts you could have learned the most from. I talked a lot about this in a previous episode from my own side of it. It's the same mechanism. You don't change what you're doing. You just stop looking at it. So here's what I actually want to hand to you today. It's a question. I like to ask questions, and you can use it on anybody.
[00:04:05] The question is, what would change your mind?
[00:04:09] Ask a trainer. Ask an instructor. Ask somebody in a Facebook group who's very confident. Ask me. And listen to what comes back. Not whether they're right, but whether they can answer the question.
[00:04:22] Somebody who's thought honestly about their own position has an answer ready because they've already gone looking for the edges of it.
[00:04:28] Somebody who's never considered it will tell you why the question itself is unfair.
[00:04:34] And then, and this is the harder part, ask yourself about whatever you currently believe about dogs and dog training. What would you have to see to change your mind? If you can't answer, it's not a crisis. It just means you might be holding a belief, not a method. And I think it's worth knowing which one you've got.
[00:04:54] So let me go first, because I don't think I should ask you to answer a question I wouldn't answer myself. Here's mine.
[00:05:02] I think when it comes to dog training, outcome is welfare. That the measure of training is what the dog's actual life is like on the whole, not just one moment or the other, but on the whole. Can they cope? Can they exist in different places out in the world? Do they have room to move in the world?
[00:05:20] So show me the dogs. If people training the way I train end up with dogs whose lives get smaller and smaller and people doing something different than me end up with dogs, living bigger lives, then I'm wrong.
[00:05:35] Not misunderstood, but wrong. And I'd want to know. And I'd say so out loud. So that's my answer. It's a real one, it's checkable, and it could actually come back against me. So that's where I'm at right now. I'm not here to tell you what to believe about dog training. The only thing I would ask is this.
[00:05:54] Whatever you believe, have some idea about what would have to happen for you to question that belief, or for you to come to believe that that belief is no longer valid.
[00:06:07] Because a belief that can't be wrong and can't be changed also can't teach you anything. It feels like strength, but it's the opposite. Nothing new ever gets in because nothing ever gets to push back.
[00:06:21] And a method that stopped learning will keep you stagnant along with it.
[00:06:27] So tell me what would change your mind? What would have to happen for you to question a belief?
[00:06:34] As I've said before, I read every one of the emails that I get from you as a listener. You can email heretohelpaisypiel.com you can leave a comment at the show
[email protected] you can subscribe and leave a rating in your podcast app of choice.
[00:06:50] I want to hear from you on this one. I think your answers are going to be probably more interesting than anything I said today.
[00:06:57] So let's hear what you believe about belief.